Profile Major Works Resources

William Graham Sumner, 1840-1910  

Influential and controversial arch-conservative economist and sociologist at Yale University.

William Graham Sumner was born in New Jersey, to a modest family of English immigrants.  His father, a self-educated industrial machinist, moved to Connecticut shortly after. William Graham Sumner was educated in Hartford's public schools. Determined on a career in the Episcopal church, Sumner went on to enroll in Yale University, obtaining his  BA in 1863, and then spent the next few years abroad in Europe - in Geneva, Göttingen and Oxford - studying ancient languages, church history and biblical scholarship. 

Sumner returned to the United States in 1866, and took a tutorship at  Yale, found his heavy teutonic brand of biblical scholarship was not really well-received.  Nonetheless, Sumner pressed on with a clerical career, and became a deacon in New Haven in 1867 and was ordained an episcopalian priest n 1869.  He served under another minister at the Calvary Church in New York, and in 1870, became a rector in Morristown, New Jersey.

Throughout all this, William Graham Sumner nurtured an interest in economics, first awaked in high school, when he stumbled upon Harriet Martineau's book. This interest finally caught fire around 1870, when he came across the sociological works of the British evolutionary theorist, Herbert Spencer.  He decided to change his career, and in 1872, accepted an academic position at Yale College.  The choice of Sumner was forwarded by the conservative Yale authorities, who wanted a cleric of impeccable credentials to counterbalance the simultaneous appointment of the more liberal and empirical-minded Francis A. Walker that same year, to the Sheffield Scientific School at Yale.  Although Sumner was appointed to Yale College as a Professor of Greek and Ancient History in 1872, he began teaching economics and other social science subjects in 1876 Sumner was instrumental in reforming the American university system away from its old "divinity-classics" roots and towards modern subjects.

For the next few years, Sumner and Walker maintained a rivalry over the soul of Yale economics, which sometimes veered into personal animosity.  Sumner's abrasive personality is believed to have driven Walker into eventually resigning from Yale in 1881. 

Thoroughly wrapped in Spencer, Sumner was an outspoken Social Darwinist and leader of the American apologist school.  Sumner defended radical laissez-faire as being justified by laws of evolution (esp. 1883), and decried any and all State interference in markets, . Sumner was an ardent opponent of bimetallism, protectionism, socialism, imperialism, etc. Sumner's famous analysis of social norms are contained in his 1907 book.

After Sumner's death in 1910, Albert Galloway Keller collected Sumner's essays and manuscripts in various books.

 

  


top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Major Works of William Graham Sumner

  • "The Causes of the Farmer's Discontent," 1873, Nation
  • History of American Currency: with chapters on the English bank restriction and Austrian paper money, to which is appended "The Bullion Report", 1874 [bk], [moa] [lib], [mis]
  • "Monetary Development", 1875, Harper's [moa]
  • "Politics in America, 1776-1876", 1876, NAR (Jan) p.47 [moa]
  • Lectures on the History of Protection in the United States, 1877
  • "Money and Its Laws", 1878, International Review (Jan), p.75
  • "What Our Boys are Reading", 1878, Scribner's [moa]
  • "The National Bank Circulation", 1878, Scribner's [moa]
  • "Professor Walker on Bi-Metallism,", 1878, Nation
  • "Socialism", 1878, Scribner's [moa]
  • "The Commercial Crisis of 1837", 1879 Scribner's [moa]
  • "Bimetallism", 1879, Princeton Review [moa]
  • "The Theory and Practice of Elections", 1880, Princeton Review, Pt. 1 (Mar, p.262)  Pt. 2 (July, p.24) [moa]
  •  "Presidential Elections and Civil Service Reform", 1881, Princeton Rev (Jan), p.129
  • "The Argument Against Protective Tariffs", 1881, Princeton Review (Mar), p.241 [moa]
  • "Shall Americans Own Ships?", 1881, NAR  [moa]
  • "Sociology", 1881, Princeton Review (Nov), p.303 [moa]
  • Political Economy and Political Science: a list of books recommended for general reading and as an introduction to special study, compiled with D.A. Wells, W.E. Foster, R.L. Dugdale and G.H. Putnam, 1881 [bk]
  • "Wages", 1882, Princeton Review (Nov), p.241 [moa]
  • Andrew Jackson as a Public Man, 1882 [bk], [1884 ed, 1887 ed, 1891 ed., ]
  • "Protective Taxes and Wages", 1883, NAR [moa]
  • "The Absurd Effort to Make the World Over", 1883 [ext]
  • "The Forgotten Man", 1883 lecture (pub. 1919 bk) [ext]
  • What Social Classes Owe to Each Other, 1883.[bk], [1884 repr, 1911 repr], [1920 ed], [lib], [mis], [ext, ext] [German 1887 trans. bk]
  • "The Survival of the Fittest", 1884,  Index
  • "Our Colleges Before the Country", 1884, Princeton Review (Mar), p.127
  • "Sociological Fallacies", 1884, NAR [moa]
  • "Evils of the Tariff System", with D.A. Wells, T.G. Shearman, J.B. Sargent, 1884, NAR [moa]
  • "Shall Silver be Demonetizied?", 1885, NAR p.485 [moa] (with Walker and Laughlin)
  • Collected Essays in Political and Social Science, 1885 [bk]
  • "Mr. Blaine on the Tariff", 1886, NAR [moa]
  • "State Interference", 1887, NAR [moa]
  • Protectionism: the -ism which teaches that waste makes wealth, 1887. [bk] [lib]
  • Alexander Hamilton, 1890 [bk, av
  • The Financier & the finances of the American Revolution, 1891
  • Robert Morris, 1892 [bk]
  • "A History of Banking in the United States", 1896, in Sumner, editor, A History of Banking in All the Leading Nations, vol.1, 1896 [bk] [lib]
  • "Prosperity Strangled by Gold?", 1896, Leslie's Weekly [1914 repr] [mis]
  • "The Fallacy of Territorial Extension", 1896, The Forum, p.414
  •  "Proposed Dual Organization of Mankind", 1896, Popular Science Monthly (Aug) p.433  
  •  "The Coin Shilling of Massachusetts Bay I & II", 1898-99, Yale Review,  Pt.I (1989, p.247) Pt. II (1899, p.405)
  • "On Empire and the Philippines", 1898
  • "The Conquest of the United States by Spain", 1899, Yale Law Journal [bk], [lib] [mis]
  • "The Predominant Issue", 1900, International Review [offpr]
  • "Concentration of Wealth: Its justification", by W.G. Sumner, 1902, The Independent, (May 1) p.1036
  • Folkways: a study of the sociological importance of usages, manners, customs, mores, and morals, 1906 [bk]
  • War and Other Essays, (ed. A.G. Keller), 1911 [bk] [lib]
  • Earth-hunger and other essays, (ed. A.G. Keller), 1913 [bk]
  • The Challenge of Facts and Other Essays, 1914 [bk] [lib], [ext, ext]
  • The Forgotten Man, and Other Essays (ed. A.G. Keller),1919 [bk] [lib] [mis]
  • The English Bank Restriction and the Bullion Report of 1810, 1920 [bk] (extract from Sumner, 1874)
  • Science of Society, with A.G. Keller, 1927. 
  • On Liberty, Society, and Politics: The Essential Essays of William Graham Sumner (ed. R. C. Bannister), 1992

 


HET

 

top1.gif (924 bytes)Top

Resources on William Graham Sumner

  • "Sumner's History of American Currency", 1874, North American Review, p.408 [moa]
  • "Sketch of William Graham Sumner", 1889, Popular Science Monthly, p.261 [repr. 1914, Challenge of Facts, p.3]
  • "Review of WG Sumner's Hamilton and other books" by Herbert L. Osgood,  1891, PSQ (Mar), p.166 [js]
  • "Review of WG Sumner's The Financier and the Finances of the American Revolution" by W.C. Ford, 1892, PSQ (Mar), p.160 [js]
  • "Autobiographical Sketch of William Graham Sumner", 1903 [repr. in 1913, Earth-Hunger, p.3]
  • "William Graham Sumner", comments by H.W. Farnam, J.C. Schwab, Irving Fisher, Clive Day, A.G. Keller and R.T. Ely, 1910, Yale Review (May), p.1
  • "Intro to William Graham Sumner" by Robert C. Bannister, 1991, at Swarthmore [online]
  • "Works of W.G. Sumner" compiled by Robert C. Bannister [online]
  • "On a New Philosophy: That Poverty is the Best Policy" (Ch. I of something)
  • "William Graham Sumner-- Social Darwinism and neo-liberalism in defense of laissez-faire by capitalism", lecture by Joseph Boland at Oregon, 1995 [online]
  • The Debate Over Government Regulation - Housing in the early 19th Century
  • Short Sumner bio at Paterson
  • "The Real William Graham Sumer" by Jeff Riggenbach, 2011 [mis]
  • "William Graham Sumner, Social Darwinist" by Miles Kimball, 2014 [blog]
  • Sumner page at ASA
  • William Graham Sumner profile at OLL, Liberty Fund
  • Sumner entry at Britannica
  • Wikipedia

 

 
top1.gif (924 bytes)Top
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

All rights reserved, Gonçalo L. Fonseca